Each article sent to the editor will be selected through an initial review process by the Editorial Board. Next, a plagiarism check will be carried out using the existing plagiarism detection tools to ensure the originality and integrity of the work. Some policies in the review of Jurnal At-Ta'dzim: Journal of Community Development include:
-
Reviewer Assignment: Reviewers with expertise in Islamic studies, social sciences, and community development will review any submitted paper.
-
Double-Blind Review: The review process employs a double-blind review, which means that both the reviewer and author identities are concealed from each other throughout the process to ensure objectivity.
-
Review Criteria: In the review process, reviewers consider the correspondence of the title, abstract, discussion (findings/community impact), and conclusions.
-
Core Assessment: Besides structural alignment, reviewers also examine the originality, scientific and social impact, the depth of community engagement, and the relevance of references used in the paper.
-
Ethical & Local Values: For manuscripts focusing on community development, reviewers will also consider the sensitivity and appropriateness of the approach regarding local wisdom and religious values.